Summary Lucio Dupuy: confirman las perpetuas para las condenadas | Se agravó la pena a la madre por el delito de abuso sexual | Página|12 www.pagina12.com.ar
2,558 words - html page - View html page
One Line
Magdalena Esposito Valenti and Abigail Pez's life sentences for Lucio Abel Dupuy's murder are upheld, but Valenti's acquittal for sexual abuse is overturned.
Slides
Slide Presentation (6 slides)
Key Points
- Lucio Dupuy: confirman las perpetuas para las condenadas
- Se agravó la pena a la madre por el delito de abuso sexual
- El Tribunal de Impugnación Penal ratificó la condena a Magdalena Espsito Valenti
- El delito de abuso sexual fue agregado a la condena de Espsito Valenti
- Descartaron la calificación de "odio de género"
Summaries
20 word summary
Magdalena Esposito Valenti and Abigail Pez's life sentences upheld for Lucio Abel Dupuy's murder. Valenti's acquittal for sexual abuse overturned.
57 word summary
Magdalena Esposito Valenti and Abigail Pez have had their life sentences confirmed for the murder of Lucio Abel Dupuy. Valenti's acquittal for sexual abuse has been overturned. The court found evidence of Valenti's involvement in the abuse and determined that it occurred at the time of Lucio's death. Claims of procedural errors and constitutional issues were dismissed.
127 word summary
Magdalena Esposito Valenti and Abigail Pez have had their life sentences confirmed by the Tribunal of Penal Impugnation for the murder of Lucio Abel Dupuy. Valenti has also been charged with sexual abuse, which she had previously been acquitted of. The court rejected the classification of "gender hatred." The prosecutor appealed Valenti's acquittal, arguing that if it was proven that Lucio suffered injuries from sexual abuse, it would be illogical to think that Valenti was unaware of these acts. After reviewing evidence from the trial, including witness testimony and messages between the defendants, the court determined that Valenti also abused Lucio and that the sexual assault occurred at the time of his death. The court dismissed claims of procedural errors and constitutional issues made by the defense.
386 word summary
The Tribunal of Penal Impugnation confirmed the life sentences for Magdalena Esposito Valenti and Abigail Pez for the murder of Lucio Abel Dupuy. Additionally, the court added the charge of sexual abuse to Valenti, which she had been acquitted of previously. The court rejected the classification of "gender hatred." The initial convictions were handed down in February by the Tribunal of Audiences in Santa Rosa. Valenti was convicted of triple murder and Pez was convicted of double murder and sexual abuse. The prosecutor appealed the acquittal of Valenti for sexual abuse, arguing that if it was proven that Lucio suffered injuries from sexual abuse, it would be illogical to think that Valenti was unaware of these acts. The court confirmed the life sentences and added the charge of sexual abuse to Valenti after reviewing evidence from the trial, including witness testimony and messages between the defendants. The court determined that Valenti also abused Lucio and that the sexual assault occurred at the time of his death. The defense argued that there were procedural errors and constitutional issues with the trial, but the court rejected these claims and reaffirmed the constitutionality of life sentences in Argentina. Lucio Dupuy was murdered on November 26, 2021, in Santa Rosa. He was last seen at 5:32 pm and was brutally beaten by both defendants between that time and 7:40 pm. The defendants left the apartment without Lucio at 7:40 pm. Pez took her girlfriend to work on a motorcycle and returned alone at 8:49 pm, where she attempted to revive Lucio by putting him under the shower. At 9:30 pm, Pez left with Lucio in her arms to take him to a nearby medical center, but it was closed. Neighbors assisted Lucio and eventually transported him to the Evita Hospital, where he was pronounced dead at 9:45 pm. The court determined that both women participated in the fatal beating, and Lucio received punches, kicks, and blows, as well as a stomp on the back from Pez. The cause of death was determined to be cerebral edema due to multiple injuries. The court also noted that the autopsy indicated that Lucio had been sexually assaulted in the weeks leading up to his death. The court rejected the defense's claims of procedural errors and constitutional issues, finding no merit in these arguments.