Summary Continuous Number Encoding for Large Language Models arxiv.org
9,059 words - PDF document - View PDF document
One Line
XVAL is a highly efficient and versatile numerical encoding scheme, outperforming others in token efficiency and demonstrating exceptional performance in arithmetic, temperature forecasting, and planetary orbit prediction.
Slides
Slide Presentation (9 slides)
Key Points
- XVAL is a novel numerical encoding scheme for Large Language Models (LLMs) that addresses the challenges of tokenizing numbers in scientific datasets.
- XVAL proposes a continuous number encoding approach that represents real numbers using a single token, resulting in a token-efficient and minimal vocabulary footprint representation.
- XVAL demonstrates improved generalization and performance compared to existing number encoding schemes in synthetic and real-world datasets.
- XVAL outperforms other encodings in temperature forecasting, showing better interpolation properties and avoiding spurious correlations in the data.
- XVAL provides the best mix of in-distribution and out-of-distribution performance among different encoding schemes and is computationally efficient.
- XVAL makes LLMs end-to-end continuous when mapping input numbers to output numbers, making it more suitable for scientific applications.
- The choice of the best encoding method depends on the problem under consideration and the desired inductive bias.
- Incorporating other statistical learning schemes and using Fourier features on the logarithm of the number can further enhance XVAL's performance.
Summaries
27 word summary
XVAL is a superior numerical encoding scheme for LLMs, surpassing other schemes in token efficiency and generalization. It excels in arithmetic, temperature forecasting, and planetary orbit prediction.
61 word summary
XVAL is a novel numerical encoding scheme for Large Language Models (LLMs) that outperforms other schemes in terms of token efficiency and generalization. It excels in tasks such as arithmetic problems, temperature forecasting, and planetary orbit prediction. XVAL overcomes the limitations of text-based encoding schemes by providing a continuous encoding scheme suitable for scientific domains, with improved generalization and computational efficiency.
134 word summary
XVAL is a novel numerical encoding scheme for Large Language Models (LLMs) that addresses the challenges of tokenizing numbers in scientific datasets. It offers a continuous number encoding approach that represents real numbers using a single token. XVAL outperforms other encoding schemes in terms of token efficiency and generalization. It excels in tasks such as arithmetic problems, temperature forecasting, and planetary orbit prediction. XVAL overcomes the limitations of text-based encoding schemes by providing a continuous encoding scheme suitable for scientific domains. It maintains continuous properties, is computationally efficient, and has improved generalization compared to existing schemes. The study compares the performance of LLMs using different encoding schemes and identifies failure modes in number inference. XVAL demonstrates superior performance in numerical tasks and out-of-distribution samples, making it a promising approach for numerical encoding in LLMs.
441 word summary
XVAL is a novel numerical encoding scheme for Large Language Models (LLMs) that addresses the challenges of tokenizing numbers in scientific datasets. It proposes a continuous number encoding approach that represents real numbers using a single token. The authors evaluate XVAL on synthetic and real-world datasets and compare it with existing number encoding schemes. They find that XVAL is more token-efficient and demonstrates improved generalization compared to other schemes. XVAL also performs well on arithmetic problems, temperature forecasting, and planetary orbit prediction tasks.
The authors emphasize that text-based encoding schemes can exploit spurious correlations in the data and struggle with long-range interactions. XVAL overcomes these limitations by providing a continuous encoding scheme that is more suitable for scientific domains. It embeds numerical values multiplicatively and orients them in a learnable direction within the embedding space.
Overall, XVAL offers a promising approach for numerical encoding in LLMs, making them more applicable to scientific datasets. It provides a token-efficient and minimal vocabulary footprint representation while maintaining continuous properties. The experiments demonstrate the advantages of XVAL in various scientific tasks, highlighting its improved generalization and performance compared to existing encoding schemes.
The study compares the performance of LLMs using different encoding schemes, including XVAL, text-based encodings, and vocabulary-sparse P10, P1000, and FP15. XVAL performs well in temperature forecasting but fails in mass prediction on the planetary dataset. Text-based encodings struggle with out-of-distribution performance. The vocabulary-sparse P10 provides the best interpolation for text-based encodings but is expensive to deploy. FP15 offers the best in-distribution performance but has poor interpolation properties and expensive embedding cost. Overall, XVAL offers the best mix of in-distribution and out-of-distribution performance and is computationally efficient.
The study also identifies failure modes of LLMs in number inference, such as predicting non-numeric tokens instead of numbers and exploiting spurious correlations. The researchers suggest that a multi-modal distribution like the categorical distribution would perform better in capturing uncertain distributions.
XVAL is proposed as a continuous number encoding that makes LLMs end-to-end continuous when mapping input numbers to output numbers. It excels in numerical tasks and leads to superior performance, especially in out-of-distribution samples. The researchers suggest incorporating other statistical learning schemes into LLMs trained with XVAL encoding and using Fourier features on the logarithm of the number to improve dynamic range.
In conclusion, XVAL is presented as a continuous number encoding for LLMs that demonstrates superior performance in numerical tasks and out-of-distribution samples. The choice of encoding method significantly affects LLM performance, and XVAL offers a good balance between in-distribution and out-of-distribution performance. The study also discusses failure modes of LLMs in number inference and suggests future directions for improving LLMs' understanding of numerics.
518 word summary
XVAL is a novel numerical encoding scheme for Large Language Models (LLMs) that addresses the challenges of tokenizing numbers in scientific datasets. It proposes a continuous number encoding approach that represents real numbers using a single token. This encoding scheme scales a dedicated embedding vector by the number value, resulting in a token-efficient and minimal vocabulary footprint representation. The authors evaluate XVAL on synthetic and real-world datasets and compare it with existing number encoding schemes. They find that XVAL is more token-efficient and demonstrates improved generalization compared to other schemes. XVAL also performs well on arithmetic problems, temperature forecasting, and planetary orbit prediction tasks.
The authors emphasize that text-based encoding schemes can exploit spurious correlations in the data and struggle with long-range interactions. XVAL overcomes these limitations by providing a continuous encoding scheme that is more suitable for scientific domains. It embeds numerical values multiplicatively and orients them in a learnable direction within the embedding space.
Overall, XVAL offers a promising approach for numerical encoding in LLMs, making them more applicable to scientific datasets. It provides a token-efficient and minimal vocabulary footprint representation while maintaining continuous properties. The experiments demonstrate the advantages of XVAL in various scientific tasks, highlighting its improved generalization and performance compared to existing encoding schemes.
The study compares the performance of LLMs using different encoding schemes, including XVAL, text-based encodings, and vocabulary-sparse P10, P1000, and FP15. The choice of encoding method significantly affects the model's performance in different tasks. XVAL performs well in temperature forecasting but fails in mass prediction on the planetary dataset. Text-based encodings struggle with out-of-distribution performance. The vocabulary-sparse P10 provides the best interpolation for text-based encodings but is expensive to deploy. FP15 offers the best in-distribution performance but has poor interpolation properties and expensive embedding cost. Overall, XVAL offers the best mix of in-distribution and out-of-distribution performance and is computationally efficient.
The study also identifies failure modes of LLMs in number inference, such as predicting non-numeric tokens instead of numbers and exploiting spurious correlations. The researchers suggest that a multi-modal distribution like the categorical distribution would perform better in capturing uncertain distributions.
XVAL is proposed as a continuous number encoding that makes LLMs end-to-end continuous when mapping input numbers to output numbers. It excels in numerical tasks and leads to superior performance, especially in out-of-distribution samples. The researchers suggest incorporating other statistical learning schemes into LLMs trained with XVAL encoding and using Fourier features on the logarithm of the number to improve dynamic range.
The study highlights the potential of XVAL and the proposed number-inference paradigm in making LLMs more suitable for scientific applications. It acknowledges the support of the Scientific Computing Core at the Flatiron Institute and funding from the Department of Energy, Office of Science.
In conclusion, XVAL is presented as a continuous number encoding for LLMs that demonstrates superior performance in numerical tasks and out-of-distribution samples. The choice of encoding method significantly affects LLM performance, and XVAL offers a good balance between in-distribution and out-of-distribution performance. The study also discusses failure modes of LLMs in number inference and suggests future directions for improving LLMs' understanding of numerics.
909 word summary
XVAL is a novel numerical encoding scheme for Large Language Models (LLMs) that aims to address the challenges of tokenizing numbers in scientific datasets. The standard tokenization schemes used in LLMs do not capture the quantitative properties of numerical data effectively. XVAL proposes a continuous number encoding approach that represents real numbers using a single token. This encoding scheme scales a dedicated embedding vector by the number value, resulting in a token-efficient and minimal vocabulary footprint representation. Combined with a modified number-inference paradigm, XVAL allows transformer models to be continuous when mapping input numbers to output numbers, making it more suitable for scientific applications.
In their experiments, the authors evaluate XVAL on synthetic and real-world datasets and compare it with existing number encoding schemes. They find that XVAL is more token-efficient and demonstrates improved generalization compared to other schemes. The authors also investigate the performance of different encodings on arithmetic problems and find that XVAL does not produce erroneous predictions like other schemes. They further evaluate XVAL on temperature forecasting and planetary orbit prediction tasks. In temperature forecasting, XVAL outperforms other encodings, showing better interpolation properties and avoiding spurious correlations in the data. In planetary orbit prediction, XVAL provides the best out-of-distribution generalization while remaining competitive in-distribution.
The authors emphasize that text-based encoding schemes can exploit spurious correlations in the data and struggle with long-range interactions. XVAL overcomes these limitations by providing a continuous encoding scheme that is more suitable for scientific domains. They also highlight the importance of imposing the appropriate inductive bias based on the continuous nature of numbers to improve model performance. XVAL achieves this by embedding numerical values multiplicatively and orienting them in a learnable direction within the embedding space.
Overall, XVAL offers a promising approach for numerical encoding in LLMs, making them more applicable to scientific datasets. It provides a token-efficient and minimal vocabulary footprint representation while maintaining continuous properties. The experiments demonstrate the advantages of XVAL in various scientific tasks, highlighting its improved generalization and performance compared to existing encoding schemes.
The study explores different number encoding methods for large language models (LLMs) and their impact on performance in various tasks. The researchers compare the performance of LLMs using different encoding schemes, including XVAL, text-based encodings, and vocabulary-sparse P10, P1000, and FP15. They find that the choice of encoding method can significantly affect the model's performance in different tasks.
In the temperature dataset, XVAL encoding provides the best results for predicting the next timestep. However, in the mass prediction task on the planetary dataset, XVAL fails to learn the correct relationship. Text-based encoding schemes struggle to interpolate properly in out-of-distribution performance. The vocabulary-sparse P10 performs poorly on in-distribution tasks but provides the best interpolation for text-based encodings. However, it is expensive to deploy due to its longer encoding length. On the other hand, FP15 provides the best in-distribution performance but has poor interpolation properties and expensive embedding cost. Overall, XVAL offers the best mix of in-distribution and out-of-distribution performance and is computationally efficient.
The study also identifies different failure modes of LLMs in number inference. One failure mode is when the model predicts a non-numeric token instead of a number, leading to invalid predictions. This failure mode becomes less frequent with more training. Another failure mode is when the model exploits spurious correlations, such as learning the distribution of digits or the length of the encoding. In the planetary orbits example, XVAL performs poorly, likely due to the high uncertainty in estimating the mass. The researchers suggest that a multi-modal distribution like the categorical distribution learned by traditional LLMs would perform better in capturing uncertain distributions.
The researchers propose XVAL as a continuous number encoding that makes LLMs end-to-end continuous when considering them as a function mapping numerical values of input to output. They demonstrate that XVAL excels in numerical tasks and leads to superior performance, especially in out-of-distribution samples. They emphasize that the choice of the best encoding method depends on the problem under consideration and the desired inductive bias.
The study also explores the possibility of incorporating other statistical learning schemes into LLMs trained with XVAL encoding. They suggest adding a Gaussian Mixture Model or any other differentiable loss to optimize the LLM's objective. They also discuss the limited dynamic range of XVAL due to direct embedding of number values in the embedding space and propose using Fourier features on the logarithm of the number to improve dynamic range.
The researchers highlight the potential of XVAL and the proposed number-inference paradigm in making LLMs more suitable for scientific applications. They note that LLMs are increasingly integrated into scientific workflows but are currently limited in analyzing data-heavy corpuses. Crafting LLMs with a better understanding of numerics can greatly enhance their usefulness in scientific analysis and discovery.
The study acknowledges the support of the Scientific Computing Core at the Flatiron Institute and funding from the Department of Energy, Office of Science. It includes references to related works on length generalization in LLMs, chatGPT failures, linear algebra with transformers, numerical reasoning over text, image recognition with transformers, and more.
In conclusion, the study presents XVAL as a continuous number encoding for LLMs and demonstrates its superior performance in numerical tasks and out-of-distribution samples. The choice of encoding method significantly affects LLM performance, and XVAL offers a good balance between in-distribution and out-of-distribution performance. The study also discusses failure modes of LLMs in number inference and suggests future directions for improving LLMs' understanding of numerics.