Summary Culture Wars and Enduring American Dilemmas press.umich.edu
12,438 words - PDF document - View PDF document
One Line
Survey data suggests that American culture is more nuanced and complex than it appears, with ambivalence and inconsistency in public opinion on moral truths and individual judgment.
Slides
Slide Presentation (11 slides)
Key Points
- American public opinion is more ambivalent and internally inconsistent than the image of a culture war implies
- Only a small percentage of conservative Protestants consistently reject abortion
- Americans exhibit both a center-seeking tendency and ambivalence towards culture war issues
- Factors such as race influence political attitudes and behavior in relation to the culture wars
- The concept of culture has been disputed and evolved over time
- People want to see culture in a bounded, essentialized, and timeless fashion, despite anthropologists denying the existence of cultural boundaries
- Views on multiculturalism depend on one's understanding of culture and its influence
- The culture wars involve a struggle for control and the attempt to define the culture, with both sides accusing each other of politicizing culture.
Summaries
26 word summary
American culture is not as divided as it may seem, as survey data reveals ambivalence and inconsistency in public opinion on moral truths versus individual judgment.
47 word summary
American culture is often seen as divided between those who believe in absolute moral truths and those who rely on individual judgment, but survey data shows that public opinion is more ambivalent and inconsistent than the image of a culture war implies. The concept of culture wars
646 word summary
American culture is often portrayed as deeply divided between those who believe in absolute moral truths and those who rely on individual judgment. However, survey data shows that American public opinion is more ambivalent and internally inconsistent than the image of a culture war implies. Most
The concept of the "culture wars" has gained attention in recent years, with a divide between orthodox and progressive views of morality cutting across various aspects of society. While the media often portrays this divide as significant, public opinion analysts suggest that only a small
Only 3% of conservative Protestants consistently reject abortion, even when a mother's health is at stake. Religious attitudes differ by gender, race, social class, and age. There is no evidence of enduring alliances across faiths, as conservative Catholics
A significant number of Americans exhibit both a center-seeking tendency and ambivalence towards culture war issues. This is evident in the divisions that occur within individuals rather than between groups. Americans hold contradictory values, with a high adherence to traditional values and a strong attachment
The culture wars thesis suggests that for political attitudes and behavior to align with the culture wars, voters must see cultural issues as important and connect them to ideologies. However, this consistency is not commonly found in public opinion and political behavior. Factors such as race
The public culture includes more than just the rhetoric of fund-seeking partisans, as it encompasses newspapers, magazines, and intellectual journals. However, these sources often result in a reduction of public discourse to reciprocal bellicosity. The opinions and assumptions presented in
Disputes about the concept of culture have been ongoing since the term was first introduced in the 1870s. While initially viewed as a set of basic values that shape one's being, by the late twentieth century, culture was seen more as
By the late 20th century, the idea that a unified culture determines behavior was being questioned. Research in cognitive psychology suggests that people have images, opinions, and information that they attribute accuracy and plausibility to, even if they are internally inconsistent
Culture wars occur because people want to see culture in a bounded, essentialized, and timeless fashion. While anthropologists deny the existence of cultural boundaries, people all over the world are marking such boundaries. In the United States, people differentiate themselves by using
The public is no longer concerned about disputes over the university canon or what constitutes essential works in curricula. Views on multiculturalism depend on one's understanding of culture, with critics arguing that it underestimates or overestimates cultural influence. Multicultural
Multiculturalists are criticized for treating culture as a fixed entity and for exaggerating its influence. Critics argue that no contemporary group can maintain a firm culture due to economic and technological change. They also challenge the idea that affiliations based on choice are superficial
Commentators from various perspectives acknowledge the influence of culture on individuals, with some recognizing the significant impact of cultural imprinting. The pervasive nature of popular culture makes it difficult for individuals to separate their thoughts from media influences. Conservatives tend to view these influences as
The culture wars in America involve a struggle for control and the attempt to define the culture. The Left accuses the Right of wanting to impose intellectual and cultural hegemony, while the Right accuses the Left of wanting to destroy traditional social habits and institutions. Both
The Left accuses the Right of politicizing culture when they dispute revisions of university curricula or the funding choices of the National Endowment for the Arts. The Right accuses the Left of politicizing culture to undermine traditional habits and institutions. Both sides in the
Critics of Lipset argue that values are not the sole explanation for American history and politics, as values can be influenced by institutional practices and historical events. Some scholars question the usefulness of the concept of values, suggesting that American individualism should be seen